While I didn’t win the Houston Writers Guild Genre Contest, I did score a 141 out of 150 points on my 15-page novel excerpt. That’s a 94%, which is still totally an A, right?
The comments I received on my novel excerpt from Naked Montréal were “strong entertaining voice” and “well-written.” They also gave me 15 out of 15 in the section of the grading rubric that said “Quit reading the MS the moment you lose interest in the story. Give the manuscript one point for each page that you read… if you made it all the way to the end, give it 15 points.” Go me! I am not boring! W00T!
I did enter in the “mainstream” genre, which I suspect had the most competition (y’know, since it’s basically the catch-all for anything that’s not mystery, romance, sci-fi, historical or YA), so I’m not too upset about this non-win (I prefer to consider it a minor setback on my ultimate road to victory, not a flat-out defeat). And two ladies actually won this genre (congrats to Pamela Hutchins of Houston and Annie Daylon of Chilliwack, B.C.!), so that’s encouraging in a world where men still seem to take most of the top writing prizes.
So basically, even though I didn’t win anything, I feel like I got something out of entering this contest. Other people have read my work and enjoyed it, plus I got some useful feedback on what needs to be improved to make the book even better.
Thanks, Houston Writers Guild!
P.S. If you’re interested in reading the sample I sent, click the “Naked Montréal” cover photo or this link.
